Air Fryer S’mores Pop Tart Recipe: Homemade Chocolate Pop Tarts

Sharing is caring!

Want to make your very own air fryer s’mores pop tart recipe? You have to hand it to Pop Tarts…jumping on that s’mores trolley was a brilliant move. But what’s really in those things anyway? 

Meh, we probably don’t want to know.

Besides, isn’t part of the fun of s’mores making them yourself? Well, not always, especially when you have little ones. 

Or when you hate camping. Or being outdoors when it’s hot.

Air Fryer S’more Pop Tarts on a plate with chocolate pieces around.

You have to hand it to Pop Tarts…jumping on that s’mores trolley was a brilliant move. But what’s really in those things anyway? 

Meh, we probably don’t want to know.

Besides, isn’t part of the fun of s’mores making them yourself? Well, not always, especially when you have little ones. 

Or when you hate camping. Or being outdoors when it’s hot.

Not a fan of S’mores? Try these easy Air Fryer Pop Tarts.

What You Will Need for S’mores Pop Tarts

  • Pre-made pie crust – This makes it even easier to whip up this homemade chocolate Pop Tarts recipe!
  • Mini-marshmallows – One of the key ingredients to make a s’more a s’more.
  • Hershey’s chocolate bars – We use a lot of Walmart brand stuff, but for proper s’mores, there is no compromise…it’s Hershey’s all the way!
  • Chocolate shell syrup – You know, the stuff that hardens right away that everyone loves on top of ice cream.
  • Graham cracker crumbs – Get these ready by crumbling up your graham crackers.
  • Cooking spray – You definitely don’t want these sticking to your air fryer!

Make Your Own Homemade Chocolate Pop Tarts Recipe

If you love your air fryer, let it show with these s’mores Pop Tarts.

You’ll want to start by preheating it as you should when you make anything in the air fryer.

Your pre-made pie crust makes it easy to get right down to business. You’ll roll it out and then cut it into the right rectangular shapes, then add some marshmallows, graham cracker crumbs, and chocolate. 

Encase those s’mores fillings with another rectangle and press the edges together. You can use a fork to make it easier, and prettier too!

Be sure you coat them with that cooking spray. This will keep them from sticking and help them get that golden color. 

But be careful…these homemade Pop Tart s’mores cook super-quick. You may want to set it for just 5 minutes and then check to see if you need to add more time. There’s nothing worse than burnt food, except the tears your kids will cry.

As soon as you start them in the air fryer, get your area ready. You’ll need to promptly smother them with the chocolate shell. And since that stuff hardens immediately, you should have your mini-marshmallows ready to go because you need to stick them into that chocolate topping. 

Once that’s complete you can devour these promptly.

The complete steps and instructions for making your own homemade chocolate Pop Tarts recipe follow below to walk you through it from beginning to end!

Love all things s’mores? Try our S’mores Pizza for dessert!

ingredients for s'mores pop tarts laid out on table.

Ingredients

  • Pre-Made Pie Crust
  • Mini Marshmallows
  • Chocolate Shell Syrup
  • Chocolate Candy Bar
  • Graham Cracker Crumbs
  • Cooking Spray

Instructions

  1. Pre-heat air fryer to 375 degrees.
  1. Roll out the pie crust and cut out rectangles.
Cut out rectangles from pie crusts.
  1. Place a few marshmallows on every other rectangle.
  1. Sprinkle graham cracker crumbs and add chocolate.
  1. Place a rectangle on top of the s’mores rectangles & press edges together with a fork.
  1. Lightly coat each rectangle with cooking spray.
  1. Place in air fryer for 5-8 minutes on 375. These fry really quick so keep an eye on them!
fried pop tarts cooling on cooling rack.
  1. Remove from air fryer and smother in chocolate shell syrup. Shell syrup hardens instantly!
  1. Stick marshmallows into the chocolate.
Adding chocolate to top of air fryer pop tarts on cooling rack.
  1. Serve & enjoy!
Air Fryer S’more Pop Tarts on a plate and cooling rack.
Air Fryer S’more Pop Tart Breakfast Pastry

Air Fryer S’more Pop Tart Breakfast Pastry

Ingredients

  • Pre-Made Pie Crust
  • Mini Marshmallows
  • Chocolate Shell Syrup
  • Chocolate Candy Bar
  • Gram Cracker Crumbs
  • Cooking Spray

Instructions

    1. Pre-heat air fryer to 375 degrees.
    2. Roll out the pie crust and cut out rectangles.
    3. Place a few marshmallows on every other rectangle.
    4. Sprinkle grams cracker crumbs and add chocolate.
    5. Place a rectangle on top of the s’mores rectangles & press edges together with a fork.
    6. Lightly coat each rectangle with cooking spray.
    7. Place in air fryer for 5-8 minutes on 375. These fry really quick so keep an eye on them!
    8. Remove from air fryer and smother in chocolate shell syrup. She’ll syrup hardens instantly!
    9. Stick marshmallows into the chocolate.
    10. Serve & enjoy!

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment

Skip to Recipe